Shirk: what breaks tawhid

Chapter 6 · about 14 min read

In short

  • Shirk means giving something that belongs only to Allah to anyone or anything else. It is the opposite of tawhid, and the greatest sin.
  • Major shirk, like praying to someone other than Allah, takes a person out of Islam. Minor shirk, like showing off or swearing by other than Allah, is a serious sin but does not.
  • Everyday traps include amulets and lucky charms, fortune tellers and horoscopes, and bad-luck omens. Ruqyah with the Quran and good dua is allowed.
  • We warn about acts, not people. Never call a Muslim a mushrik. Teach gently, and leave judging to Allah.
  • The door of repentance is always open. Allah forgives every sin, even shirk, for anyone who turns back to Him before death.
Take the short lessonsThe key points of this chapter, a few screens at a time, with a quick check at the end.

Why this chapter matters

In Tawhid: Allah is One we learned the heart of Islam: Allah alone creates, Allah alone is worshipped, and nothing is like Him. This chapter is about the opposite of tawhid. Its name is shirk.

Shirk comes from an Arabic word that means to share or to make a partner. In Islam, shirk means giving something that belongs only to Allah to anyone or anything else.

  • It is the greatest sin. Nabi ﷺ was asked which sin is the greatest. He said: to set up a rival to Allah, when He alone created you1.
  • It is a great wrong. Luqman told his son: do not make partners with Allah. Shirk is a terrible wrong2. It gives the rights of the Creator to the created.
  • It is the one sin Allah does not forgive if a person dies on it. Allah forgives anything less than that to whoever He wills34.

That sounds heavy. But please read this chapter with a calm heart. We learn about shirk the way a doctor learns about an illness: to protect ourselves and the people we love, not to point fingers. And the door back to Allah is always open, as the last section shows.

Sources for this section
  1. 1(Bukhari 4477)
  2. 2(Quran 31:13)
  3. 3(Quran 4:48)
  4. 4(Quran 4:116)

What shirk is

Tawhid has three sides, so shirk can happen in three ways:

Tawhid saysShirk would be
Allah alone creates, owns and runs everything.Believing someone else can bring good or remove harm by their own power, without Allah.
Allah alone deserves worship.Giving any act of worship to someone else: dua, sujud (prostration), sacrifice, vows.
Allah's names and qualities are His alone.Giving a creature a quality that is only Allah's, like knowing the unseen or knowing everything.

The kind people meet most

The people of Makkah in Nabi's ﷺ time believed Allah was the Creator. Their shirk was in worship. They prayed to idols and to righteous people of the past, and said: we only worship them so they bring us closer to Allah5.

Allah answers: do not call on anyone besides Allah6. And about those people call on: if you call them, they do not hear you. And even if they heard, they could not answer you7.

So the key rule is simple: worship, and dua most of all, goes to Allah alone. You can ask a living person for help they are able to give, like a ride or a loan. That is normal life. But asking anyone, living or dead, for what only Allah can give, like a child, a cure or forgiveness, is giving them worship. The chapter Worship and dua explains this in more detail.

Sources for this section
  1. 5(Quran 39:3)
  2. 6(Quran 72:18)
  3. 7(Quran 35:14)

Major and minor shirk

Scholars explain that there are two levels of shirk:

Major shirkMinor shirk
What it isGiving worship, or a quality of Allah, to someone else.Smaller acts and words that lean toward shirk. Nabi ﷺ called them shirk as a warning.
ExamplesPraying to an idol, a grave or a saint. Bowing in worship to anyone but Allah. Believing a charm or a person controls your fate.Showing off in worship. Swearing by other than Allah. Saying "what Allah and you want".
EffectIt takes a person out of Islam. It cancels their good deeds.It does not take a person out of Islam. It is a serious sin, and it can spoil the deed it touches.
If someone dies on itNot forgiven8. Allah has forbidden Jannah to it9.A serious sin. Scholars differ on whether Allah may forgive it without repentance, like other big sins. So repent from it.

Nabi ﷺ also gave us good news. A man asked him about the two things that decide everything. He said: whoever dies not making any partner with Allah will enter Jannah. And whoever dies making partners with Him will enter the Fire10. So protecting your tawhid is the most important thing you will ever do.

Some acts can be major or minor, depending on the belief behind them. For example, wearing a charm while believing it protects you by itself is major shirk. Wearing it while believing Allah protects you through it is still minor shirk, because Allah never made it a cause. Both are wrong. The fix for both is the same: take it off and trust Allah.
Sources for this section
  1. 8(Quran 4:48)
  2. 9(Quran 5:72)
  3. 10(Muslim 93)

Hidden shirk: showing off

Riya means doing a good deed so that people see it and praise you. Nabi ﷺ called it hidden shirk.

He once came to his Companions while they were talking about the Dajjal (the great deceiver before the end of time). He said: shall I tell you about something I fear for you more than the Dajjal? It is hidden shirk: a man stands to pray, and makes his prayer look better because he sees someone watching him11.

Why is it shirk? Because the deed was meant for Allah, but you gave a share of it to people. Allah says: I need no partner. Whoever does a deed for Me and for someone else as well, I leave him with his partner12.

Allah tells us how to keep a deed safe: whoever hopes to meet his Lord, let him do good deeds, and not make anyone a partner in the worship of his Lord13. And Nabi ﷺ warned: whoever does good so people hear of it, Allah will show people what he really intended14.

The full story: the first three people judged

Nabi ﷺ said that on the Day of Judgement, the first people to be judged include three men who did great deeds15.

The first died fighting. Allah reminds him of His blessings, and he says: I fought for You until I was killed. Allah says: you are lying. You fought so people would call you brave, and they did.

The second learned and taught, and recited the Quran. He says: I did it for You. Allah says: you did it so people would call you a scholar and a fine reciter, and they did.

The third was rich and gave in every good cause. He says: I spent for You. Allah says: you did it so people would call you generous, and they did.

All three got what they wanted: people's praise in this world. But they had nothing left for the next16.

What this teaches us

  • The size of a deed is not enough. What counts is who it was for.
  • Even the best deeds need checking: fighting for Allah, teaching, and charity.
  • People's praise is a poor reward. It is gone in a moment. Allah's reward lasts.

Do not let the fear of riya stop you

Shaytan has a trick here too. He whispers: "you are only praying to be seen, so stop." Scholars teach: do not stop a good deed out of fear of showing off. Fix your intention and carry on.

  • A passing thought is not riya. If the thought comes and you push it away, it does not spoil your deed. Scholars explain that riya harms when you accept it and act for it.
  • Being praised is not riya. Nabi ﷺ was asked about a man who does a good deed and people praise him for it. He said: that is the early good news for the believer17.
  • Some deeds are public by nature, like praying in the masjid or teaching. Do them, and keep checking your heart.

Simple cures

  • Before a deed, ask yourself: who am I doing this for?
  • Keep some good deeds secret: a night prayer, a charity, a dua for someone, that only Allah knows about.
  • Remember that people cannot give you anything Allah has not written for you18. Their praise cannot help you, and their blame cannot harm you, except by Allah's will.
  • Ask Allah often to make your deeds sincere.
Sources for this section
  1. 11(Ibn Majah 4204)
  2. 12(Muslim 2985)
  3. 13(Quran 18:110)
  4. 14(Bukhari 6499)
  5. 15(Muslim 1905)
  6. 16(Muslim 1905)
  7. 17(Muslim 2642)
  8. 18(Tirmidhi 2516)

Words that lean toward shirk

Some everyday sayings are minor shirk. People often say them out of habit, without thinking. Now that you know, you can change them.

Swearing by other than Allah

Nabi ﷺ heard Umar swearing by his father. He said: Allah forbids you to swear by your fathers. Whoever swears, let him swear by Allah, or stay quiet19. He also said: whoever swears by other than Allah has committed kufr or shirk20.

  • Not allowed: "I swear on my mother's life", "by my children", "by the Kabah", "on my honor", "by the Prophet".
  • Allowed: swearing by Allah, or by one of His names or qualities. Most scholars also allow swearing by the Quran, because it is Allah's speech.
  • Said it by habit? Say la ilaha illallah, and try to drop the habit. No need for panic.

"What Allah and you want"

Nabi ﷺ said: do not say "what Allah wills and so-and-so wills". Say: "what Allah wills, and then what so-and-so wills"21. The word "then" keeps Allah's will first. In the same way, say "if it were not for Allah, and then you", not "if it were not for Allah and you".

Giving the credit to the stars

One morning after rain, Nabi ﷺ said that Allah had said: some of My servants woke up believing in Me, and some disbelieving. Whoever says the rain came by Allah's mercy believes in Allah. Whoever says it came because of a certain star believes in the star22. Today, a weather forecast is fine. It reads the clouds and the wind, which Allah made. The problem is giving the credit to something other than Allah.

Sources for this section
  1. 19(Bukhari 6646)
  2. 20(Tirmidhi 1535)
  3. 21(Abu Dawud 4980)
  4. 22(Bukhari 846)

Amulets and lucky charms

Many cultures have objects that people believe bring luck or keep harm away. A blue eye bead, a red string on the wrist, a horseshoe on the door, a lucky coin, a hand charm, a bone, or something hung in the car.

Nabi ﷺ said: spells, charms and love-potions are shirk23. And: whoever hangs something on himself is left to it24. In other words, Allah leaves you to the charm you trusted, and the charm can do nothing.

Even the Companions had to unlearn old habits. On the way to Hunayn, they passed a tree where the idol worshippers hung their weapons for luck. Some of them said: make us a lucky tree like theirs. Nabi ﷺ said: SubhanAllah! This is like what the people of Musa said: make us a god like their gods25. He corrected them, and he did not call them disbelievers.

What is allowed: ruqyah

Ruqyah means reciting the Quran and duas over a sick or troubled person. It is allowed and good.

  • Some Companions asked Nabi ﷺ about the ruqyah they used before Islam. He said: show me your ruqyah. There is no harm in ruqyah as long as it has no shirk in it26.
  • When Nabi ﷺ was ill, he recited the last two surahs of the Quran and blew over himself27.
  • Good ruqyah uses clear words: the Quran, Allah's names, and duas you can understand. Strange words, unknown names, numbers and squares are warning signs.

What about an amulet with Quran in it?

Scholars differ. Some early scholars allowed wearing a small case with ayat of the Quran in it. Others did not, because the hadith about charms is general, and because it opens the door to other charms and to taking the Quran into dirty places. Many scholars today say: the safer way is to recite the Quran, not wear it. That is what Nabi ﷺ did.

The evil eye is real28, and so is the harm of magic. Islam's protection is dua, the morning and evening adhkar, and the Quran, not beads and strings. The chapter Jinn, magic and the evil eye explains how to protect yourself.
Sources for this section
  1. 23(Abu Dawud 3883)
  2. 24(Tirmidhi 2072)
  3. 25(Tirmidhi 2180)
  4. 26(Muslim 2200)
  5. 27(Bukhari 5735)
  6. 28(Muslim 2187)

Fortune tellers, horoscopes and omens

Allah says: no one in the heavens or on earth knows the unseen except Allah29. The future is part of the unseen. So anyone who claims to know your future is claiming something that belongs to Allah alone.

Fortune tellers

  • Visiting one: Nabi ﷺ said: whoever goes to a fortune teller and asks him about anything, his prayer is not accepted for forty nights30. Scholars explain that he still must pray. He just loses the reward of those prayers.
  • Believing one: whoever goes to a fortune teller and believes what he says has disbelieved in what was sent down to Muhammad ﷺ31.
  • This covers palm reading, tarot cards, reading coffee cups, crystal balls, and people who "see" your future for money.

"But sometimes they are right!" The Companions asked the same thing. Nabi ﷺ said: a jinn steals a true word and pours it into the fortune teller's ear, and he mixes it with a hundred lies32.

Horoscopes and star signs

Nabi ﷺ said: whoever learns a part of astrology has learned a part of magic, and the more he learns, the more he takes in33. Astrology means claiming the stars tell your character or your future. It is different from astronomy, the science of the sky, which Muslims have always used for prayer times, the qibla and the moon.

Reading your horoscope "just for fun" is still asking something other than Allah about the unseen. Scholars warn against it. Delete the app. You lose nothing.

Bad-luck omens

Before Islam, the Arabs would let a bird fly. If it flew right, they went ahead. If it flew left, they stayed home. Nabi ﷺ said: there is no bad omen. And he liked a good word that gives hope34. He said: taking bad omens is shirk. He said it three times. Then Ibn Masud added: every one of us feels a little of it, but Allah removes it through trust in Him35.

  • Examples today: black cats, broken mirrors, the number 13, "touch wood", a certain day or month being unlucky. Nabi ﷺ said there is no bad luck in the month of Safar either36.
  • A passing feeling is human. The sin is letting it stop you or decide for you. Say your Bismillah, trust Allah, and carry on.
  • Hoping from a good word is fine, like feeling glad when you hear the name "Sa'id" (happy) on your way to an exam.
Sources for this section
  1. 29(Quran 27:65)
  2. 30(Muslim 2230)
  3. 31(Abu Dawud 3904)
  4. 32(Bukhari 5762)
  5. 33(Abu Dawud 3905)
  6. 34(Bukhari 5754)
  7. 35(Abu Dawud 3910)
  8. 36(Bukhari 5757)

Warn about acts, do not judge people

Knowing about shirk is to protect yourself first. It is not a tool to judge others.

  • Never call a Muslim a mushrik or a kafir. Nabi ﷺ said: if a person calls his brother "disbeliever", it comes back on one of them37.
  • We cannot see hearts. In a battle, Usama killed a man who had just said la ilaha illallah. Usama thought he only said it out of fear. Nabi ﷺ was very upset and said: did you cut open his heart to see?38.
  • Many people do these things without knowing. A grandmother who ties a red string on a baby, or an uncle who swears by his children, usually learned it from their own family. They need kindness and teaching, not labels.
  • Speak about the act, not the person. Say "this charm is not from Islam", not "you are a mushrik". Judging a particular person is for qualified scholars and courts, and in the end for Allah.

Remember how Nabi ﷺ corrected the Companions who asked for a lucky tree39. He was clear about the act, and gentle with the people.

Sources for this section
  1. 37(Bukhari 6104)
  2. 38(Muslim 96)
  3. 39(Tirmidhi 2180)

The door is always open

If you read this chapter and thought "I have done some of these things", that thought is a gift from Allah. It means your heart is alive.

Allah says: O My servants who have wronged themselves, do not lose hope in Allah's mercy. Allah forgives all sins40. All sins, for anyone who turns back to Him.

  • Even shirk is forgiven with repentance. The Quran speaks of those who called on other gods, killed and committed zina, and then says: except those who repent, believe and do good. Allah will change their bad deeds into good deeds41.
  • Many Companions once worshipped idols. When Amr ibn al-As became Muslim, he worried about his past. Nabi ﷺ told him: Islam wipes out what came before it42.
  • The verse about shirk not being forgiven43 is about a person who dies on it. While you are alive, the door is open.

What to do

  • Stop the act: take off the charm, delete the horoscope app, drop the oath.
  • Feel sorry in your heart, and ask Allah to forgive you.
  • Say la ilaha illallah with meaning, and renew your trust in Allah.
  • Replace the old habit with a good one: morning and evening adhkar instead of a charm, dua instead of a fortune teller.
Sources for this section
  1. 40(Quran 39:53)
  2. 41(Quran 25:68-70)
  3. 42(Muslim 121)
  4. 43(Quran 4:48)

Common questions

My grandmother gave my baby a blue eye bead. What do I do?
Take it off gently, and thank her for her love. Protect your baby with the duas Nabi ﷺ used and the last surahs of the Quran. If she asks, explain kindly that we trust Allah alone. Do not make it a family fight.
I read my horoscope for fun. Is that really so bad?
Scholars warn against it, because it treats the stars as if they know the unseen44. Even "for fun", it slowly shapes how you think about your day. Delete the app, ask Allah's forgiveness, and move on.
I am scared of showing off, so I stopped praying sunnah at the masjid.
Go back to praying it. Stopping good deeds out of fear of riya is one of shaytan's tricks. Fix your intention, push away the passing thought, and keep some other deeds secret.
I say "I swear on my mother" all the time. Am I a mushrik?
No. It is a sinful habit of the tongue, a kind of minor shirk, not leaving Islam. Swear only by Allah, or better, do not swear much at all. Each time it slips out, say la ilaha illallah.
Can I go to a sheikh for ruqyah?
Yes, if he uses the Quran and known duas in clear words45. Be careful of anyone who asks your mother's name for "calculations", writes squares and numbers, asks for strange items, or tells you who did magic on you. You can also do ruqyah for yourself.
A family member visits a fortune teller. How do I talk to them?
Choose a calm moment, show care, and share the hadith46. Help them with what they are really worried about: money, marriage, health. Make dua for them. Do not call them names.
Sources for this section
  1. 44(Abu Dawud 3905)
  2. 45(Muslim 2200)
  3. 46(Muslim 2230)

This guide teaches what all of Ahl al-Sunnah agree on and notes where the schools of creed differ. For your own questions, ask a scholar you trust or your local masjid.

All of Aqidah