Men and women

Chapter 12 · about 14 min read

In short

  • Islam honors men and women the same. Both are servants of Allah, both get the same reward, and the best person is the one with the most taqwa.
  • Men and women who are not mahram to each other can meet, work, study and pray in the same places, with good manners: lower the gaze, dress modestly, speak properly, and do not be alone together in private.
  • Most scholars say do not shake hands with a non-mahram of the other sex. Some scholars today allow a handshake with no desire when refusing would cause real harm. Follow a scholar you trust.
  • If a man and a woman like each other, Islam gives them a clean and happy way: a proposal, the families, and marriage.
  • Zina is a major sin. But the door of repentance is wide open, and Muslims never shame or expose each other.
Take the short lessonsThe key points of this chapter, a few screens at a time, with a quick check at the end.

Dignity first

Before any rule, Islam starts with respect. Allah created us all from a single soul, and from it its mate1.

  • Same worth. Allah made us into nations and tribes to know each other. The most honored of you with Allah is the one with the most taqwa (mindfulness of Allah), not the man or the woman2.
  • Same reward. Allah says: I will not let the work of any of you be lost, male or female. You are from one another3.
  • Named side by side. One ayah lists believing men and believing women, the patient, the truthful, the fasting, and promises all of them a great reward4.
  • Partners. Nabi ﷺ said: women are the counterparts of men5. He also said: the best of you is the best to his wife6.

So the rules in this chapter are not about one side being less. They protect the honor of both and keep hearts and families safe. The rules are few, and the rest of life is open.

Sources for this section
  1. 1(Quran 4:1)
  2. 2(Quran 49:13)
  3. 3(Quran 3:195)
  4. 4(Quran 33:35)
  5. 5(Abu Dawud 236)
  6. 6(Tirmidhi 3895)

Lowering the gaze

The first rule is for the eyes, and Allah gives it to both men and women, one after the other:

  • Tell the believing men to lower their gaze and guard their private parts. That is purer for them7.
  • And tell the believing women to lower their gaze and guard their private parts8.

Lowering the gaze does not mean walking with your eyes on the floor. It means: do not look at someone with desire, and do not keep looking at what is not yours to look at. Looking at a person you are talking to, in a normal way, is fine.

The first glance

Your eyes will sometimes land on something by accident. That is not a sin. Nabi ﷺ told Ali: do not follow one look with another. The first is for you, but the second is not910. Jarir asked him about a sudden look, and Nabi ﷺ told him: turn your eyes away11.

How Nabi ﷺ taught it

At Hajj, young al-Fadl was riding behind Nabi ﷺ. A woman came to ask a question, and al-Fadl kept looking at her. Nabi ﷺ gently turned al-Fadl's face away, and answered her question12. No shouting, no shaming, and she was not sent away.

Why it matters

  • Nabi ﷺ said that the eyes have their own kind of zina, and it is looking. The tongue's is talking, and the heart wishes. Then the body either does it or does not13.
  • The same rule covers screens. Pictures and videos that stir desire are part of guarding the eyes. See Phones and the internet.

Nabi ﷺ also gave young people a practical tip: marry if you can, because it helps you lower your gaze. If you cannot yet, fast, because it calms desire14.

Sources for this section
  1. 7(Quran 24:30)
  2. 8(Quran 24:31)
  3. 9(Abu Dawud 2149)
  4. 10(Tirmidhi 2777)
  5. 11(Muslim 2159)
  6. 12(Bukhari 6228)
  7. 13(Bukhari 6243)
  8. 14(Bukhari 5066)

Who is a mahram

A mahram is a man a woman can never marry, because he is too closely related to her. With a mahram, the rules of this chapter are relaxed: she can be alone with him, travel with him, and be less covered in front of him15. Allah lists the closest relatives you may never marry16.

HowMahram for a woman
By birthHer father and grandfathers, her sons and grandsons, her brothers, her brothers' and sisters' sons (nephews), and her father's and mother's brothers (uncles)
By marriageHer husband's father, her husband's son from another wife, her mother's husband (once that marriage is complete), and her daughter's husband
By breastfeedingThe same relatives through a woman who nursed her as a baby. What is forbidden by birth is forbidden by nursing17

For a man, it is the same list the other way round.

Not mahram, even though they feel like family: cousins, a husband's brother, a sister's husband, a wife's sister, a fiance, an adopted brother or sister (unless nursed by the same mother), and friends of the family. With them, the normal rules apply. Treat them with warmth and respect, but not as mahram.
Sources for this section
  1. 15(Quran 24:31)
  2. 16(Quran 4:23)
  3. 17(Bukhari 2645)

Being alone together (khalwah)

Khalwah means a man and a woman who are not mahram being alone together in a private place, where no one can see them or walk in. This is clearly not allowed. Nabi ﷺ said: no man should be alone with a woman unless she has a mahram with her1819. He also said: when a man is alone with a woman, shaytan is the third20.

Nabi ﷺ warned most about the people we relax with. Asked about the husband's relatives, like his brother, he said: the in-law is death21. The closest danger is the person no one watches.

What counts as khalwah

  • Is khalwah: a closed room or office with the door shut, a house with no one else home, a private car ride with just the two of you, a hidden meeting.
  • Is not khalwah: an open office, a shop, a classroom, a park, a busy street or train, a masjid with people around, a room with the door open where others can see in.

A short, unplanned moment, like a lift or a taxi, is lighter than a planned, hidden meeting. Keep it short and proper.

Avoid giving people the wrong idea

One night Nabi ﷺ walked his wife Safiyyah back from the masjid. Two men passed by and hurried on. He called out: wait, this is Safiyyah, my wife, because shaytan can put a bad thought in a mind22. Making things clear protects hearts and names.

Sources for this section
  1. 18(Bukhari 5233)
  2. 19(Muslim 1341)
  3. 20(Tirmidhi 2165)
  4. 21(Bukhari 5232)
  5. 22(Bukhari 2035)

Touching and shaking hands

Scholars agree that touching with desire, like hugging, holding hands or kissing someone you are not married to, is haram. They also agree that touch in a real need is allowed: a doctor or nurse treating a patient, saving someone who fell, helping someone in an accident. An accidental touch in a crowd is no sin at all.

The question people ask most is the handshake with someone of the other sex who is not mahram. Here there are two views.

View 1: avoid it (most scholars)

  • This is the view of most scholars, past and present, and of the four schools for a young non-mahram.
  • Their evidence: Aisha said the hand of Nabi ﷺ never touched the hand of a woman who was not his. He took the women's pledge with words only2324. He said himself: I do not shake hands with women2526.
  • Some classical scholars, especially Hanafis, allowed it with a very elderly person where there is no desire at all.

View 2: allowed without desire where refusing harms

  • Some scholars today allow a simple, short handshake, with no desire and no fear of temptation, when refusing would cause real harm: offending a colleague, a new Muslim's family, losing a job, or giving a bad picture of Islam.
  • Their evidence: Nabi ﷺ not doing something shows what is best, but does not by itself make it haram. They also point out that a servant girl of Madinah could take Nabi ﷺ by the hand and lead him wherever she wanted27.
  • They agree it should not be started by the Muslim, and that avoiding it is better when it is easy.

Both views are held by real scholars. Follow a scholar you trust, and do not look down on a Muslim who follows the other view.

A kind way to decline. Smile, put your right hand on your chest, and say something warm: nice to meet you, I do not shake hands, but it is a real pleasure. Most people respect it, especially if you say it before the moment becomes awkward.
Sources for this section
  1. 23(Bukhari 5288)
  2. 24(Muslim 1866)
  3. 25(Nasai 4181)
  4. 26(Ibn Majah 2874)
  5. 27(Bukhari 6072)

Work, school, university and the masjid

In Nabi's ﷺ time, men and women met in the market, the masjid and the street. When the men took up all his time, the women asked for a day of their own to learn, and he gave it28. Islam does not ask for two separate worlds. It asks for good manners when they meet.

Good manners when men and women meet

  • Lower the gaze, as above.
  • Dress modestly, both men and women. See Clothing and covering.
  • Speak properly. Allah told the wives of Nabi ﷺ: do not speak too softly, so that someone with a sick heart wants something, but speak in a proper way29. Scholars take the lesson for everyone: be clear, polite and normal, not flirty.
  • No khalwah, no touching with desire.
  • Keep it about the work or study. Friendly is good. Flirting is where the line is crossed.

Scholars differ on how much mixing is good. Some say it is fine with these manners wherever there is a real reason, like work, study and medicine. Others prefer separate spaces wherever possible. Both want clean hearts. Follow a scholar you trust.

At the masjid

  • Nabi ﷺ said: do not stop the women servants of Allah from the masjids of Allah30.
  • Men prayed in front and women behind. Nabi ﷺ said the best rows for women are the back rows31.
  • After salah, Nabi ﷺ stayed in his place for a while, so the women could leave first without crowding at the door32.

So every masjid should give sisters a clean, welcoming space and a way to ask questions.

The full story: Musa at the well of Madyan

Musa ran away from Egypt and came to the water of Madyan. A crowd of shepherds was watering their animals. To one side, he saw two young women holding their flock back. He asked them: what is wrong? They said: we cannot water until the shepherds leave, and our father is a very old man33.

So Musa watered their flock for them. Then he went back to the shade and made dua: my Lord, I am in need of whatever good You send down to me34.

One of the women came back to him, walking with shyness. She said: my father is calling you, to pay you for watering for us35. Musa met the father and told him his story.

The daughter said to her father: hire him. The best one to hire is strong and trustworthy36. And the father said to Musa: I want to marry you to one of my two daughters37.

What this teaches us

  • Talking for a need is fine. Musa spoke to the women, short and polite, and helped them.
  • Modesty on both sides. He did his good deed and walked away. She spoke clearly and with shyness.
  • The family was part of it. When there was interest, it went through the father, and it ended in marriage.
Sources for this section
  1. 28(Bukhari 101)
  2. 29(Quran 33:32)
  3. 30(Bukhari 900)
  4. 31(Muslim 440)
  5. 32(Bukhari 837)
  6. 33(Quran 28:23)
  7. 34(Quran 28:24)
  8. 35(Quran 28:25)
  9. 36(Quran 28:26)
  10. 37(Quran 28:27)

Talking and messaging online

Phones have made it easy to be alone together without being in the same room. A private chat late at night can do what a closed door does. Many scholars treat secret, flirty chatting like a form of khalwah.

  • Talk for a reason. Work, study, a group project, a family matter: fine. Keep it clear and polite38.
  • Use group chats where you can, instead of one-to-one chats.
  • The family test: would you be happy for your parents, your spouse, or their spouse to read it? If not, stop.
  • No late-night chats, private photos, flirty voice notes or secret accounts.

The zina of the tongue is talk39, and today much of that talk is typed. See also Phones and the internet.

Sources for this section
  1. 38(Quran 33:32)
  2. 39(Bukhari 6243)

When you want to marry: the halal way

Liking someone is not a sin. Feelings come, and Allah knows that40. Islam does not ask you to kill the feeling. It shows you a clean road for it. Nabi ﷺ said: for two people who love each other, there is nothing like marriage41.

The steps

  • Make your intention clear. If you are serious, say so, and bring it to the families. Allah says: do not make secret promises to each other42.
  • Pray istikhara, the dua asking Allah to choose what is good. Nabi ﷺ taught it for every important matter43.
  • Look for good religion and character. Of wealth, family, beauty and religion, Nabi ﷺ told us to choose religion44.
  • You may look at each other. A man told Nabi ﷺ he was going to marry a woman. He asked: have you looked at her? Go and look at her45. It is more likely to bring love between you46.
  • Meet and talk with family around, not alone. Ask the real questions. See questions to ask before marriage.
  • Her yes matters. A woman may not be married without her consent47.
  • The nikah (marriage contract), with the wali (her guardian, usually her father), witnesses and the mahr (the gift to the bride).

The wali

  • Most scholars (Malikis, Shafi'is, Hanbalis): the wali is required. Nabi ﷺ said: there is no marriage without a wali4849.
  • Hanafis: an adult woman's marriage can be valid without her wali if the match is suitable. They still see the family's blessing as the best way.
Engaged is not married. Until the nikah, the two of you are still not mahram. The engagement time is for getting to know each other with the family, not for being alone together. Do not propose to someone who is already engaged to someone else50. For the whole road after the wedding, see the Marriage page.
Sources for this section
  1. 40(Quran 2:235)
  2. 41(Ibn Majah 1847)
  3. 42(Quran 2:235)
  4. 43(Bukhari 6382)
  5. 44(Bukhari 5090)
  6. 45(Muslim 1424)
  7. 46(Ibn Majah 1865)
  8. 47(Bukhari 5136)
  9. 48(Abu Dawud 2085)
  10. 49(Tirmidhi 1101)
  11. 50(Bukhari 5142)

Zina, and the open door

Zina means sexual relations between a man and a woman who are not married to each other. All Muslims agree it is one of the major sins. Allah says: do not come near zina. It is a shameful thing and an evil way51. He lists it with shirk and murder as things the true servants of Allah stay away from52.

Notice: do not come near. The rules on the gaze, khalwah, touch and chatting are fences that keep you far from the edge.

But the door is open

Right after that warning, Allah says: except those who repent, believe and do good. Allah will change their bad deeds into good deeds53. And He says to everyone who went too far: do not lose hope in Allah's mercy. Allah forgives all sins54.

  • A man once kissed a woman who was not his wife, and came to Nabi ﷺ full of regret. Allah sent down: good deeds remove bad deeds55. The man asked: is this just for me? Nabi ﷺ said: for all of my ummah56.
  • When a man came to Nabi ﷺ to confess zina, the first thing Nabi ﷺ told him was: go back, ask Allah's forgiveness and repent to Him57. Private repentance between you and Allah is the way.

How to repent

  • Stop the sin, regret it, and decide not to go back.
  • Close the doors that led there: delete the chat, block the number.
  • Do good: pray, give charity58.
  • Keep it covered. Do not tell people. Nabi ﷺ said everyone in his ummah can be forgiven except the person who sins at night, Allah covers it, and in the morning he tells everyone what he did59.

If you fall again, repent again. Allah does not tire of forgiving.

Sources for this section
  1. 51(Quran 17:32)
  2. 52(Quran 25:68)
  3. 53(Quran 25:70)
  4. 54(Quran 39:53)
  5. 55(Quran 11:114)
  6. 56(Bukhari 526)
  7. 57(Muslim 1695)
  8. 58(Quran 11:114)
  9. 59(Bukhari 6069)

Never shaming

Islam is strict about the sin, but it is gentle with people and very strict about people's honor.

  • Cover, do not expose. Nabi ﷺ said: whoever covers a Muslim, Allah will cover him in this world and the next60.
  • Do not spread it. Allah warns those who love to see shameful things spread among the believers61. Forwarding a rumor or a screenshot is spreading it.
  • Do not accuse. Accusing a chaste woman of zina without four witnesses is itself a major sin with a heavy punishment62. Guesses and gossip are not proof.
  • The child is never to blame. No soul carries the burden of another63. A child born outside marriage has the full dignity of any Muslim.
  • Do not judge by looks. A sister without hijab may be closer to Allah than you think. Advise kindly and privately, or not at all. See she does not wear hijab.

Among the seven people in Allah's shade on the Day of Judgement is a man invited to sin by a beautiful, high-ranking woman, who said: I fear Allah64. That is the goal, and it is about your own heart, not other people's.

Sources for this section
  1. 60(Muslim 2699)
  2. 61(Quran 24:19)
  3. 62(Quran 24:4)
  4. 63(Quran 6:164)
  5. 64(Bukhari 660)

Things people think are haram but are not

  • Saying salam or hello to someone of the other sex, politely. The Companions used to greet an old woman they knew after Jumuah, and she fed them65.
  • A woman speaking to men for a need. Women asked Nabi ﷺ questions in front of men66. Most scholars say a woman's voice is not something she must hide. The rule is the way she speaks, not that she speaks67.
  • Having feelings for someone. Feelings are not a sin. What you do with them is what counts68.
  • Seeing a doctor of the other sex when needed. Choose your own sex if it is easy, but health comes first.

For more, read things you think are haram and are not, and How halal and haram work.

Sources for this section
  1. 65(Bukhari 6248)
  2. 66(Bukhari 6228)
  3. 67(Quran 33:32)
  4. 68(Quran 2:235)

Common questions

A new coworker of the other sex puts out her hand to shake mine. What do I do?
Most scholars say avoid it. Smile, hand on your chest, and say kindly that you do not shake hands. Some scholars today allow a short handshake with no desire if refusing would cause real harm. Follow a scholar you trust, and be gentle either way.
My manager wants to meet me alone in her office with the door closed.
Ask politely to leave the door open, or meet in a glass room or an open area. Most workplaces are happy with this. It protects you both.
Can my brother-in-law drive me to work every day when no one else is in the car?
He is not your mahram, and Nabi ﷺ warned most about in-laws69. Try to have someone else ride along, or find another way. A short trip in a real emergency is different.
I like a sister at the masjid. How do I go about it?
Do not message her in secret. Talk to your family, or ask the imam or a trusted person to contact her family. If both sides agree, meet with family around, pray istikhara, and move toward the nikah.
Are my cousins my mahram?
No. Cousins can marry each other, so they are not mahram. Be kind and close as family, but the normal rules of covering and not being alone apply.
I did something with someone before marriage and I feel I can never be forgiven.
You can. Allah says do not lose hope, He forgives all sins70. Stop, regret, close the doors, do good, and keep it between you and Allah. Do not tell people.
Sources for this section
  1. 69(Bukhari 5232)
  2. 70(Quran 39:53)

This guide teaches what scholars agree on and gives the main views where they differ. For your own situation, ask a scholar you trust or your local masjid.

All of Halal and Haram